Showing 2 of 14 debates
Moral intuitions are evolutionary artifacts that often mislead modern ethics
Our moral intuitions evolved to help small hunter-gatherer groups survive, not to solve complex ethical dilemmas in modern society. Research in behavioral economics and evolutionary psychology shows that these intuitive moral responses often lead us astray when dealing with contemporary issues like global poverty, climate change, or AI ethics. For example, studies demonstrate that people feel more compelled to help one identifiable victim than thousands of statistical victims - a bias that makes no logical sense but reflects our ancestral environment where we only interacted with people we could see. Similarly, our intuitive sense of fairness often focuses on intentions rather than outcomes, leading to support for policies that feel morally satisfying but produce worse results for everyone involved. When designing ethical frameworks for modern challenges, we should rely more heavily on empirical evidence about what actually reduces suffering and increases wellbeing, rather than trusting gut feelings that were optimized for a world that no longer exists. This doesn't mean abandoning all moral intuitions, but rather recognizing their limitations and supplementing them with data-driven approaches to ethics.
Youth sports should prioritize fun and development over winning at all costs
Having coached hundreds of young athletes, I've witnessed firsthand how an obsession with winning can crush a child's love for sports and damage their self-worth. When we make everything about trophies and championships, we rob kids of the joy that drew them to the game in the first place. I've seen too many talented players quit by age 14 because the pressure became unbearable, and parents screaming from sidelines turned what should be play into stress. Sports at the youth level should teach life lessons - resilience, teamwork, effort, and grace in both victory and defeat. These lessons stick with kids long after they hang up their cleats. When we emphasize development over winning, kids learn to push through challenges, support teammates, and find satisfaction in personal growth. Yes, competition matters and kids should learn to compete, but the scoreboard shouldn't define their worth or our coaching success. The real victory is when a player who struggled all season finally makes that shot, or when a shy kid finds their voice as a team leader. That's character building that lasts a lifetime.